Written by Matt Stevenson
Here’s the xG which favours Liverpool, although not by much if the penalty hadn’t been given, prompted by VAR. The first 25 minutes were even, Liverpool dominating possession and carving out one chance from a corner where Lerma was alert to get back onto the line to head away a van Dijk header (rated 1 in 3). We had a break away with Ouattara through against Allison, a heavy touch as he went around him took the change away, although the algorithm rated it as 1 in 2. On 28 minutes we took the lead. A quick counter attack, Neto’s ball to Smith and Smith’s pass with the outside of his foot set Ouattara free who powered past Van Dijk to cross for Billing to stroke home (1 in 2). Liverpool only had one more chance before the break. A header from Van Dijk, which he put wide (1 in 3) very similar to a miss when Nottm Forest beat Liverpool. We probably expected an onslaught in the second half, but Liverpool were strangely muted. They only had two big chances in the entire 45 minutes, both essentially in the same incident. Jota heading a chance (1in 4) into Smith’s outstretched arm having jumped. It is arguable whether he raised his arm on the way down, but when the referee went to the monitor we all knew what to expect. This leaves only one team without a penalty award in the Premier League. Salah blazed wide (4 in 5) and then Liverpool created nothing until injury time, both from Gakpo, and minor chances.
Man of the match against Liverpool
O.Dango
Billing
Lerma
Neto
Senesi
Anthony
Rothwell
Kelly
Someone else
There’s been a lot of debate about the formation (and best formations) on different threads. The average positions show a back four, with almost a narrow bank of six (in two clumps of three). There looked to be lots of space behind Smith (15) although Liverpool didn’t exploit this, and where Man City had found the gap behind Zemura, the pace of Kelly (5) was key to preventing too much going down this wing, which is sterling work given he was up against Salah and Alexander-Arnold. Both wingers (Ouattara 11 and Anthony 32) were helping defensively which could explain their relative depth being level with Rothwell (14) and Lerma (8). In terms of substitutions, we didn’t overly retreat – Mepham was stripped to come on, but didn’t, which was interesting – we tried to protect the lead but were still trying to counter attack. Christie (10) came on for Billing (29) who had been booked. On 80 minutes, Lerma (8) was replaced by Cook (4) had Fredericks (2) for an injured Smith (15) with both sitting deeper. With 2 minutes to go, Semenyo (24) came on for Solanke (9) and Vina (18) replaced Anthony (32) the latter being the most defensive substitution of the 5.